HomeWHICHWhich Is The Best Interpretation Of The Graph

Which Is The Best Interpretation Of The Graph

Graphs communicate important quantitative information in a visual format and are often used to communicate health and medical information. Much of the HPE curriculum involves students being presented with information in graphical form. Using this form of representation, students must:

  • know how to interpret graphs
  • to elicit key information
  • extract the basic information
  • draw conclusions
  • compare and contrast and
  • provide recommendations.

Individuals with higher levels of graphical literacy are better able to find information in graphs, and they spend more time looking at conventional features of graphs to generate more accurate interpretations (Okan, Galesic & Garcia-Retamero, 2015).

Teachers should explicitly teach the meaning-making (semiotic) systems of graphical representations before having students analyse graphs (see ‘Explicitly teaching text structure’ and ‘Reading and unpacking visual representations of data’ ). This includes explaining:

  • the importance of headings
  • labelling of axes
  • scaling of axes (for example, linear or logarithmic)
  • use of colour
  • choice of graph type (for example, pie chart, line graph, bar graph, column graph).

Additional strategies to support students to read graphs can be found in ‘Language for graphs and statistical displays’.

Refer to more articles:  Which Ring Goes On Top

Using sentence starters to analyse graphs

Sentence starters are one way to scaffold students’ interpretation of graphs. Sentence starters provide a focal point for students to begin writing (or saying) an interpretation of the data they are viewing in graphical form.

Sentence starters can range in their cognitive demand, moving from identifying information and patterns in the graph to generating comparisons, predictions, and hypotheses.

Sentence starters teachers can provide students include:

  • This graph shows …
  • A pattern I notice in the graph is …
  • An anomaly/outlier/different pattern in the graph is …
  • A difference between … and …. is …
  • A similarity between … and … is
  • If this pattern continued, I predict …
  • A probable reason for that pattern is …
  • A probable reason for this difference is …
  • When I first looked at this graph …
  • The data that most stood out to me was …

The example below provides some completed sentences a Year 7 or 8 student wrote after viewing a graph about the types of drinks consumed by Australian children (VCHPEP129).

a line graph showing the average amount of sugar-sweetened beverages (mL/day) consumed per capita, by age group on day of survey. The age groups in the graph are 2-3, 4-8, 9-13, 14-16. The drinks shown are soft drink, fruit juice, fruit drink, sports drink, cordial, energy drink.

Source: Figure 3 in Boden Institute, University of Sydney 2014. Evidence Brief Obesity: Sugar-Sweetened Beverages, Obesity and Health. Australian National Preventive Health Agency, Canberra.

    • This graph shows the types of drinks drunk by Australian children.
    • A general pattern I notice in the graph is that as the child’s age increases, they drink more of these kinds of drinks.
    • A reason for this pattern might be because older children can go out and buy their own drinks.
    • A different pattern in the graph is that energy drinks go down for 14 to 16-year old.
    • A reason for this pattern might be because they prefer drinking other drinks.
    • The data that most stood out to me was that sports drinks were drunk more than soft drinks.
Refer to more articles:  Which Statement Is A Common Mentoring Myth

Using a framework to interpret graphs

In HPE, students write with a specific purpose as they communicate their interpretations to others. Students aim to explain, critique, and analyse real-world data relating to health, well-being, and physical activity.

As students become more capable of interpreting data on their own, they can be given frameworks to help structure independent analyses of graphs, whether spoken or written.

One framework to use to analyse a graph is given below. Depending on the length of analysis and information in the graph, the framework could be used to create one paragraph or several.

a framework to support students to analyse graphs. It suggests a written analysis of a graph follows the following sequence: introduction, trend 1, additional trends, anomalies or differences, conclusion or recommendation. For each section, instructions are given to explain what the student should write. For introduction: describe what the graph shows, identify any patterns or trends. For trend 1: describe the trend or pattern, provide evidence from the graph. This is repeated for additional trends. For anomalies or differences: describe the difference or anomaly and provide evidence from the graph. For conclusion or recommendations, students should rephrase the main trend and information the graph provides in general terms and, if required, provide a recommendation for further action.

Below are two samples showing how a Year 9 or 10 student has applied the framework to interpret two different graphs (VCHPEP148).

a column graph showing the estimated societal costs of alcohol misuse in Australia. Percentage of total cost is given along the y-axis. The four areas of society listed are criminal justice system (20.6% of total costs or 2.958 billion dollars), health system (11.7% of total costs or 1.686 billion dollars), Australian productivity (42.1% of total costs or 6.046 billion dollars) and traffic accidents (25.5% of total costs or 3.662 billion dollars)

Source: Manning, M., Smith, C., & Mazerolle, P. (2013). The estimated societal costs of alcohol misuse in Australia. Trends and Issues in Crime and Criminal Justice no. 454. Canberra: Australian Institute of Criminology

Student sample response

a column graph showing notified cases of laboratory-confirmed influenza by month in Victoria, 2011-2014.

Source: Surveillance of notifiable infectious diseases in Victoria, 2011-2014

Student sample response

RELATED ARTICLES

Most Popular

Recent Comments