Here is the answer and explanation to the question In the play Trifles,do you think that the murder of Mr. Wright is justified in any way? Why or why not? As a crime, would it be any more/less…
In the play Trifles, do you think that the murder of Mr. Wright is justified in any way? Why or why not? As a crime, would it be any more/less justifiable today? Why or why not?
You are viewing: Who Killed Mr Wright In Trifles
In the play Trifles, do you think that the murder of Mr. Wright is justified in any way? Why or why not? As a crime, would it be any more/less justifiable today? Why or why not? I believe Minnie’s murder of her husband was justified because she had been abused both verbally and physically for years by her husband. Although women have more opportunities today to get away from an abusive relationship, I still believe Minnie’s actions were justified based on the fact that she did not commit this act on a whim but instead it was a moment of desperation and self-defense.
Bạn đang xem: In the play Trifles,do you think that the murder of Mr. Wright is justified in any way? Why or why not? As a crime, would it be any more/less…
Justifiable means defensible, and Minnie Wright’s murder of her husband, if perhaps a poor choice, is defensible. The play is at pains to make this point.
We can understand why Minnie snapped and killed her husband. We learn from Mrs. Hale, who knew Minnie for years, that she was once a bright, outgoing woman. By the time of the play, she had been isolated for a long time with a cold-hearted husband. The couple has no children, and the canary, which sang as Minnie used to, was her only company. Minnie apparently identifies with the canary and sees it as similar to the light-hearted person she once was. She breaks when her husband kills this beloved bird. In the literal death of the canary, Minnie probably saw the metaphoric death of all she once was—and at the hands of the same man who diminished her spirit. Also, as Mrs. Peters points out when she recounts a boy hacking her helpless kitten to death with an axe, watching a defenseless animal be murdered can fill a person with rage. Minnie’s act is, therefore, defensible. She was abused and witnessed abuse.
The question of whether her murder would be more or less justifiable today could be answered both ways. It might be more justifiable because we know that people who are violent to animals often move to become violent to humans. In that way, the killing of the canary was a sign that Minnie was in danger. However, women today have an easier time divorcing their husbands, are less stigmatized for doing so, and have many more opportunities to find work outside the home. With that in mind it would be more reasonable to ask why Minnie didn’t leave her abusive situation. However, we also know that leaving doesn’t necessarily free a woman from stalking or the threat of death at the hands of an ex-husband. We could therefore make a case that Minnie had justifiable grounds to fear for her life.
Read more : Who Originally Sang I Swear
I personally believe Minnie should have left rather than murder her husband, but I do think what she did is defensible. She didn’t do it on a whim, or because she wanted to inherit his money, or to run away with a lover. She did it because of abuse.
Intentional murder is never justified, regardless of the offense, which is why Minnie Wright should not be acquitted of murdering her husband. However, one can sympathize with her difficult situation and understand her motivation for strangling John Wright while he was sleeping. Minnie suffered from domestic violence and lived with a callous, abusive husband. In addition to suffering from domestic abuse, Minnie lived an isolated, lonely life on the homestead. She was alienated and could not socialize with other women. Under the oppressive reign of her abusive husband, Minnie silently suffered for an extended period of time, and her mental health gradually diminished.
John Wright callously killed Minnie’s pet canary, which was the only thing near and dear to her heart. The death of Minnie’s canary was the final straw that finally broke her sanity. Shortly after John Wright killed Minnie’s canary, she ended his life by strangling him in his sleep. Some may argue that John Wright received what he got. They might believe that Minnie was justified for murdering her abusive husband. However, if one were to completely exonerate Minnie’s actions, they would be indirectly promoting violence. In my opinion, violence begets violence. No one has the right to take the life of another human being, regardless of the offense. Minnie would certainly be charged with first-degree murder in today’s society but it would be difficult to determine her sentence. Minnie’s mental anguish, declining sanity, and abusive home life would play a significant role in determining her sentence.
Further Reading
- https://thcslequydoncaugiay.edu.vn/topics/trifles
- https://thcslequydoncaugiay.edu.vn/topics/trifles/characters
- https://thcslequydoncaugiay.edu.vn/topics/trifles/themes
The murder of Minnie Wright’s husband was the consequence of pent up, disturbed and emotional chaos caused by an extended period of domestic violence. Minnie was isolated in the middle of nowhere. She was also isolated from her peers and from the rest of society.
As a result, she was under an incredible amount of mental and psychological stress. When John Wright decided to take his abuse one step further and chooses to kill the only thing that Minnie had left, her canary, Minnie loses the last of her mental faculties. Perhaps she did not want her abuse to be transferred to that which she loved. She then snaps and kills her husband.
Life is not ours to take. Unfortunately, Minnie Wright had nobody to defend her from the monster that her husband had become. All that she had was her canary, her misery, and her loneliness. Grief can play tricks on one’s mind and, when extreme grief hits, crazy things can happen.
Read more : How To See Who I Am Following On Facebook Android
The women were concerned because they knew that evidence that proved a “snap” would confirm the men’s suspicions about Minnie having killed her husband.
Crime is never justifiable. It always leads to chaos and tragedy. It is simply too sad that Minnie had to implode and then explode the way that she did. It could have been preventable, but certainly also avoidable. John Wright has the same right to live as everyone else. That he made his wife’s life miserable there is no doubt. Did he ask for what he got? Indirectly, yes. It is not justifiable, but it is expected that a slave will rebel to a master the way the abused goes against the abuser. It is action and reaction, but it is never ever justifiable to take a human life. Or any life, to that effect.
Do you find that the article In the play Trifles,do you think that the murder of Mr. Wright is justified in any way? Why or why not? As a crime, would it be any more/less…
If not, please leave a comment below the article so that our editorial team can improve the content better
Post by: THCS LeQuyDon
Category: question
#play #Triflesdo #murder #Wright #justified #crime #moreless #eNotescom
Source: https://t-tees.com
Category: WHO
